fernandopa

November Assassination #3 (SG Win / PAGY)

5.7 hours

Please consider liking my review on Steam - it means a lot to me!

Dordogne is a game I would only recommend to diehard point-and-click adventure games, and even then, barely. While it's an artistical masterpiece, it is a chore to play. It does very little, and the little it does is subpar.

To justify that, I want to discuss three aspects of the game I think carry the most weight: narrative, presentation and gameplay.

Starting with presentation. The game is, undoubtedly, an artistic achievement. It looks and sounds great, and there's no mistaking the artistry behind the people who developed it. Each scene and location are hand painted in watercolor, and while the level of detail varies a lot, it is always recognizable and evocative. Character models are highly-stylized and just coherent, I love the way their eyes and mouths kind of 'fly' on their face, which is a beautiful effect and entirely intentional. Even the small touches such as the sticker designs are fabulous. The music is nothing I'll be listening after beating the game, but it's quite evocative and helps to envelop you in the environment you're in. Voice acting is not present in every interaction, but where it is, it's really competent and helps to drive home the moments being portrayed, although I believe the game would have benefited immensely from a default French narration from end to end. And here is kind of where I stop with the compliments, because I move onto the next aspect: narrative.

Narrative-wise, the game starts with a strong premise, but keeps tripping over itself as the game proceeds. I think I lost interest around the halfway mark, when the story between Mimi and its dad became very caricate and heavy-handed, and a new (important) character is introduced with very little backstory, explanation or foresighting, just to become the emotional crux of the whole plot. It is obvious what the game wants you to feel, but in between too much exposition, too little gameplay and a heavy-handedness in the narrative style, you never really feel it for yourself. So when the game wants you to care about a certain scenario, you just don't. And by the end, the game takes a narrative tailspin in a very short time, leaving you disoriented and unsatisfied with the resolution it presents. It feels like the artists behind the game spent 80% of their time painting all locations, only to remember they needed a narrative and decided to spend 10% of their time on it, with gameplay getting the final 10%. Which probably tells you already what I think of it …

Gameplay, as should be no surprise to anyone at this point, is not something I enjoyed. It's a point-and-click adventure game, so I know the pace will be slower than what I tend to like, but surprisingly a decision was made to untie movement from p&c towards traditional 3D navigation. But, your character move slowly, which is not a massive deal when you're in a small house, but starts to get annoying once you move to open areas such as the garden and forest. The game has this constant habit of forcing you to stop whatever you are doing to do mini-environmental-puzzles such as brushing your teeth or pouring milk on your cereal or browsing for a scarf on a closet, and while those interactions are supposed to be tactile, they are just clunky, unfun and kill the pace. Think of games like Venba or Assemble With Care where you need to perform those manual things with your controller, just that here not a single one of those interactions is fun or work well. Once the pace has been killed and you've been taken away again from the game to these mini-puzzles, there's no coming back. Besides that, the game hides several collectables throughout each level in the forms of tapes, stickers, words and sounds, and while the tapes are visible on the world, all other collectables are only 'visible' and 'interactable' once you're near them. So if you're looking to 100% the game, or even engage a bit further with the narrative, be prepared to stop whatever you're doing, figure out where the game wants you to go for progression purposes, avoid it like the plague, and sweep each square pixel of the map for hidden collectables before doing so. By the third chapter I was already sick of doing that, and even by doing that I was able to miss collectables God knows where, which frustrated me and convinced me that abandoning this altogether was the happy path for me, at which point at least the pacing helped me to know what was going on. It's just a collection of poor decisions and implementation choices that defeat any chance the game had of being fun.

Should you play it? If you're not a point-and-click enthusiast, I would stay away from it. Life is short and there are too many games out there that are more fun than this one. Even if you love point-and-click games, there are many other better ones for you to tackle before buying this. Buyer beware