Mskotor
November 2026
Next update (works only on profile page)
Overall
backlog
progress
:
The good 👍
- It feels like the old HP games, e.g. Philosopher's Stone
- The game includes all the major spells known from the books
- A lot of freedom to explore and collect junk, if you fancy
- Good voice acting
- Combat is well executed
- Manual save system
- Story mode for those who don't want to fight or are bad at combat
The bad 👎
- Dialogue animations are very stiff
- The story ends in a predictable way
- Keeping your chosen look is annoying: the "I want my cape to look like X" transmog resets every time you change to better gear
- The Hogwarts map is hard to read, and the castle feels too big. But I'm sure bigger fans than me will love it
- Alohomora has a very annoying minigame
- It crashed every 1-2h, and none of the manual fixes I tried helped
- The main character is very bland
- Except for 3 character side-quests, all side-quests are fetch quests
- There are no repercussions for using unforgivable spells
Conclusion:
What the game does well is Hogwarts' atmosphere. The castle, Hogsmeade, the graphics and the overall vibe are magical. The puzzles are also a nice throwback to old HP games.
What it does poorly is, well, pretty much everything else. It is not an RPG, as there are no choices or consequences of our actions. The world is big and open, but also empty, apart from a multitude of collectible fetch quests and repetitive mini-dungeons. The story is predictable and on rails. Combat is well executed, but why is a 15-year-old mowing through hordes of goblins and dark wizards twice their age? Why do professors say we need to work hard to catch up on 4 years of education (we start in year 5, as we are so special), and then accept that we spend half of our time running around clearing goblin bandit camps? There is not enough story, especially since from around the halfway point it progresses mainly through completing trials, with few cutscenes in between.
There are also things missing from the game. The morality system was cut, reportedly after the death of one of the lead developers. There is no punishment for using Avada Kedavra on enemies and people at school (though people at school are at least untouchable...). No Quidditch. No duels. No social interactions. No relationships. It is sad that those never got implemented, even though some of them were being worked on during production.
- It feels like the old HP games, e.g. Philosopher's Stone
- The game includes all the major spells known from the books
- A lot of freedom to explore and collect junk, if you fancy
- Good voice acting
- Combat is well executed
- Manual save system
- Story mode for those who don't want to fight or are bad at combat
The bad 👎
- Dialogue animations are very stiff
- The story ends in a predictable way
- Keeping your chosen look is annoying: the "I want my cape to look like X" transmog resets every time you change to better gear
- The Hogwarts map is hard to read, and the castle feels too big. But I'm sure bigger fans than me will love it
- Alohomora has a very annoying minigame
- It crashed every 1-2h, and none of the manual fixes I tried helped
- The main character is very bland
- Except for 3 character side-quests, all side-quests are fetch quests
- There are no repercussions for using unforgivable spells
Conclusion:
What the game does well is Hogwarts' atmosphere. The castle, Hogsmeade, the graphics and the overall vibe are magical. The puzzles are also a nice throwback to old HP games.
What it does poorly is, well, pretty much everything else. It is not an RPG, as there are no choices or consequences of our actions. The world is big and open, but also empty, apart from a multitude of collectible fetch quests and repetitive mini-dungeons. The story is predictable and on rails. Combat is well executed, but why is a 15-year-old mowing through hordes of goblins and dark wizards twice their age? Why do professors say we need to work hard to catch up on 4 years of education (we start in year 5, as we are so special), and then accept that we spend half of our time running around clearing goblin bandit camps? There is not enough story, especially since from around the halfway point it progresses mainly through completing trials, with few cutscenes in between.
There are also things missing from the game. The morality system was cut, reportedly after the death of one of the lead developers. There is no punishment for using Avada Kedavra on enemies and people at school (though people at school are at least untouchable...). No Quidditch. No duels. No social interactions. No relationships. It is sad that those never got implemented, even though some of them were being worked on during production.
Details
☐ Bare-bone ☑ Average ☐ Good |
We are gifted in using ancient magic and can see its traces. We are so special that we were missed when the Hogwarts invitations went out, so now we join in the 5th year, just before important exams, and need to fast-track 4 years of learning into one. All while solving the mystery around our powers, stopping a goblin rebellion and surviving relentless attacks from dark wizards. Easy peasy. The main story is better at the beginning. Later on we focus on completing 4 trials of old, powerful wizards to uncover biography of another ancient magic wielder. The problem is that the story is predictable after the second trial, so we rush through the last two trials already knowing the "big revelation". The game ends with an "epic battle" and a predictable "for emotional value" death. It is all very rail-roaded. Side stories are interesting and expand the universe. There are 3 side-stories of other 5th-year students: one from Gryffindor, one from Slytherin and one from Hufflepuff. The Ravenclaw story is missing, it must have been cut due to budget / time limits. The game has remnants of the morality system that was cut from the final version. We are warned against using dark magic, and we can refuse to learn specific dark spells. And then we can throw them left and right: around school, in villages and in fights. It feels a bit fragmented and immersion-breaking. |
☐ Boring ☑ Average ☐ Good |
It is an impressive game, and there are quite a lot of things to do, even if most of them are filler. The game is full of HP atmosphere. We can grab a Butterbeer in Hogsmeade, or a cupcake in the castle kitchen. We can fly around the open world to enjoy the views, or race other students. Explore the castle and the wilderness. Solve simple environmental puzzles, or collect a multitude of collectibles (which also give us HP universe backstory). There is a simple day/night cycle. So it is a great title to immerse yourself in the HP atmosphere. Sadly, apart from that, the gameplay loop is very repetitive. Arrive at the quest giver. Travel to the location. Kill enemies and/or retrieve an object. Return for the reward. Guardian trials feel like puzzle dungeons from old HP games, though they are quite focused on combat as well. Interactions with professors are very limited and superficial. Each one teaches us 1 spell from the main storyline, plus an optional additional spell if we do some fetch quests for them. The game benefits a lot from the fast travel system, otherwise arriving at the necessary locations would be very repetitive. |
☐ Basics (walk, jump etc.) ☐ Magic / powers ☑ Advanced combat |
We can run, jump, fly on a broom anywhere outdoors, fly on a hippogriff and ride tank-sized monstrosities. We can cast an enormous number of spells. We can use levitation on cats and cows to watch them helplessly wiggle their legs mid-air. We can cast a fireball to light lanterns or cast camouflage to stealthily take down enemies in a bandit camp one by one. We can grow plants like Mandrakes and angry cabbages and use them in fight. We can brew potions (though I relied on health potions found on enemies and never needed to brew anything). There is a simple experience / abilities system where we can improve spells (Glacius can freeze nearby enemies, Stupefy curses enemies etc.), potions / combat plants and passive buffs (like the number of spell slots available or better stealth abilities). We can respec specific skills, which is useful as reaching higher levels later on gets very grindy. |
☐ Clunky and stiff ☐ Adequate ☑ Fluid and enjoyable |
Flying on a broom takes a bit of getting used to, but apart from that there are no issues. Platforming elements are well executed and controls are responsive. There is no "but I thought I pressed the button on time to avoid this attack" feeling. Some keys on PC are weirdly assigned, but it's possible to remap them all. Why is Wingardium Leviosa controlled with V/F/Q/E instead of using the mouse wheel? And why, after pressing Shift to turn on "turbo" on the broom, I still need to hold "forward" in order to steer the broom with the mouse? Little things like that. |
☐ Basic ☑ Detailed ☐ Over complicated |
The menu feels a bit clunky. Direct shortcuts open the map, inventory, abilities etc. But pressing Esc once does not take us back to the game, it opens the master menu, and another Esc is needed to resume. Loading of master menu is slow, so the whole experience is a slog. Changing gear is annoying, as pretty much all better pieces of clothing look ridiculous and make us look like a clown. Transmog is not explained, I stumbled on it by chance. And then, each time we change gear, the transmog is reset, so we get the "ridiculous look" once again. We need to go to the gear slot, select "yes pls override this ugly clothes", open the menu with a multitude of options, select something, and go back to the gear menu. Rinse and repeat for each single piece of gear: glasses, outfit, gloves, cape, hat, scarf. I sometimes found myself not using better gear, as I could not be bothered with all this hassle. The alternative was to look like a clown in cutscenes. We collect a lot of facts along the way, but there is no "read all" option in the collectibles menu. We can re-decorate the Room of Requirement, but it is a bit clunky as it requires placing rotatable objects in 3D space with object collision. It made me think of building camps in Fallout 76. The areas where we can keep pets have a limit on how many objects we can place before the game runs out of memory / resources, same as in F76 lol. |
☐ Boring and generic ☐ Average ☑ Good ☐ Great |
I
I do like the combat in this game. Enemies are responsive and have a good repertoire of spells and attacks, though they can get buggy: stuck in an object, or repeat the same spell over and over again. Enemies can raise shields, which need to be dispelled with a specific type of magic: red barriers with attack spells, purple with manipulation spells (Accio, Depulso etc.), yellow with state spells (Glacius, Arresto Momentum, Leviosa). It means we need a set of all available spells, instead of using the same spell across all fights. We can dodge attacks or parry them. If we time the parry right, we respond with a counter-attack that can leave the enemy confused for a few seconds. We can also use ancient magic, which boils down to filling the ancient magic meter by killing enemies and doing specific actions (like dodging an unparryable attack in time). Ancient magic attacks deal tons of damage, and usually take the form of calling down thunder from the skies. I found combat manageable on hard difficulty, but if you struggle, it's possible to play on story-first difficulty, where combat is way more forgiving. It is also possible to sneak around and use Petrificus Totalus on enemies. It works on all humans and gnomes, but is not viable on animals and trolls. Althought it is not a stealth game. No elevation gain to find a good position, enemy patrol routes are extremely basic, and enemies have clear auto-aim on us and spot us easily. Later in the game we learn Imperio as a mind-control spell. It is fun to cast it on an enemy and have them fight each other. Rinse and repeat. It is quite slow though, and gets tedious fast. Enemies also go back to their patrol routes like nothing happened when effect wears off, even when they say things like "you will not control my mind!". It is a bit immersion-breaking. They should go and look for the player, not act like nothing happened. |
☑ None ☐ Skins ☐ "Time-savers" ☐ Direct purchase ☐ Custom currency (gems etc.) |
☐ None ☐ Story progression ☐ Few collectibles / easy to get ☑ Grindy collectibles / hard to get ☐ Require multiple playthroughs |
☐ No saves ☐ No saves, progress carries over ☐ One checkpoint, too rare ☐ One checkpoint, frequent ☑ Manual saves |
☐ Can run on potato ☐ Medium requirements ☑ High requirements ☐ Too low for what is visible on screen ☐ Optimization disaster |
☐ May look good 10 years ago, but not now ☐ Blurry textures / geometry problems ☐ Average ☑ Good ☐ Beautiful |
☐ Nothing to remember ☑ Good voice acting ☐ Good weapons & effects ☐ Good OST ☐ Music flows well with the action |
☐ Resolution, volume only ☐ Basic graphic settings ☑ Advanced graphic settings ☐ Adjustable HUD ☑ Accessibility options |
☐ No map ☑ Basic ☐ Detailed ☐ Minimap ☑ Fast travel |
Side note
Bouldering/climbing is harder than it looks. All those games where the main character is kicked out from their comfy life, into a jungle where they climb vertical walls like goats - ha, not happening. Amount of strength one need to have in their fingers to hold to small holds is crazy. 🧗♀️
So far I like it more than archery. Another game-activity tried in real life ✅
Well, I also went on shooting range during the summer. So I guess that gives me 3 activities. I am not escaping police chase with a stolen car for the next one 🤣