Impressive game (also my first from the Sherlock Holmes series) - maybe I am a little biased. Impressive graphics, pleasant gameplay, puzzles ok, not too absurd, I liked the fast travel implementation and the Sherlock abilities that helped a lot.

A lot of puzzles, funny situations, very enjoyable and puts your mind to contribution. I didn't understand / used too much the workshop part, even the achievements were somehow obscure to get. The minigames shouldn't be part of this awesome game. They were just too childish and the controls were unnatural.